posted in: Retirement Planning

Is It Better to Take My Super as a Lump Sum, or as Income?


It’s one of the most common questions I’m asked by people approaching retirement. After years of building up a superannuation balance, should you draw it out as a lump sum or take it as an income stream? The answer depends on your situation, but there is a bigger question sitting underneath it, which is whether your money will last as long as you do. Once you understand that, the lump sum versus income decision becomes much easier to make.

In this article, I’ll walk through why your retirement savings may need to last far longer than you expect, what happens when a lump sum is parked in a savings account, why the real question is how your money is invested rather than where it sits, when taking a lump sum can make sense, and why property can be a tricky asset to rely on once you have stopped working.

Your Money May Need to Last 40 Years or More

Most people picture retirement as a stage of life that might last 20 years or so. For a lot of people retiring today, that estimate is too short.

We’ve got people now living well into their 90s. With medical advancement, there’s no reason why they might not live past 100. So if you’re retiring at 60, we need this portfolio to last 40 years, maybe 50 years, maybe 60 years, who knows? So it’s important that this portfolio, while giving you an income, is also actually growing every year and keeping pace with inflation.

That changes how a retirement portfolio has to be built. It is not enough for your money to pay you an income for a few years. It needs to keep paying that income for decades, and it needs to keep growing so that the same income still buys the same lifestyle as prices rise.

What Happens When You Park a Lump Sum in the Bank

To show why growth matters, in the above video I use a simple example of someone taking their super out as a lump sum and putting it somewhere that feels safe.

Let’s say, for example, you took a lump sum. You had $2 million invested in super, we’ll assume it’s in a tax-free environment, and you took it all outside of superannuation and invested in a savings account and got 3% per annum.

There would also be tax issues in moving money out of super, which I set aside in the video to keep the example simple. Even without them, the maths is uncomfortable.

Let’s say you’re getting about $60,000 of income off that savings account, 3%. When you spend your $100,000, you’ve spent more than what you started with, so your portfolio will end the year at $1.96 million.

The savings account feels safe because the balance never drops on a bad day in the markets. But if you need $100,000 a year to live and the account only earns $60,000, the shortfall comes straight out of your capital, and it keeps coming out of your capital for as long as that gap remains.

What Your Portfolio Should Be Doing Instead

The target is not simply to cover your spending. It is to cover your spending and still finish the year with a balance that has kept up with rising prices.

What we actually want to see is your balance be worth $2.06 million, because if your balance is $2 million, we want to produce you an income of $100,000 and then we want to produce another return to make sure that portfolio is keeping pace with inflation. And if inflation is 3%, we want the balance to be $2.06 million.

The gap between $1.96 million and $2.06 million might not look dramatic after one year, but it is the difference between a portfolio that is slowly running down and one that is sustaining itself. Stretch that over 30 or 40 years and you end up with two very different retirements.

It’s Not About Being In or Out of Super

So it’s not necessarily about whether it’s in or outside of super. Superannuation has a lot of fantastic tax benefits we want to take advantage of. But it’s more important to make sure that it’s invested in a way where your portfolio is going to be sustainable and provide you a long-term income, but ideally not too volatile either.

Whether your money sits inside super or outside it is a structural question, and super’s tax benefits are often a strong reason to keep money there. But the decision that matters most is how the money is invested. You want enough growth to keep pace with inflation and fund your income for the long term, without so much volatility that a bad year in markets puts the whole plan at risk.

When a Lump Sum Can Make Sense

That doesn’t mean taking a lump sum is always a mistake. There are good reasons to draw some money out.

You might, for example, pull money as a lump sum out of superannuation if you had a mortgage to pay off, or maybe you’ve got a loan on an investment property you need to pay off.

Clearing debt as you move into retirement can reduce the income you need each year and remove a fixed cost that would otherwise eat into your portfolio. The key is to take out money that has a clear purpose, rather than pulling everything out simply because you can.

Why Property Can Be a Tricky Retirement Asset

Investment property often comes up in this conversation, and it is worth being clear about how it behaves once you are relying on it for income.

Let’s assume you’ve got a million dollar house in suburban Australia. Let’s say it’s getting $40,000 a year of rent and you’re paying about $10,000 of other costs like agency fees, insurance, council rates, water rates. You’re getting a net return of 3% in terms of income.

That property may well keep growing in value, and in the video I’m happy to assume it will. The issue is the income. A million dollars tied up in one asset producing $30,000 a year is fine, but the same money in a share portfolio might generate closer to 5%. There is a second problem as well.

One of the problems with property is you’re either in or out. So when you’re retired, you can’t just sell a bedroom if you need access to some cash, you’ve got to sell the whole asset.

In retirement, flexibility matters. You may need cash for a new car, a family emergency or a big trip, and an asset that can only be sold all at once makes that much harder to manage.

Now an important distinction here is that when you’re working, properties can be a fantastic way to build wealth. The ability to leverage negative gearing tax deduction can be very effective. So I’m really just talking about people in retirement here.

I’m not making a case against property here. The point is that the asset which helped you build wealth during your working life won’t necessarily be the right one to fund your retirement.

So, Lump Sum or Income: Which Is Right for You?

There is no single right answer, because it depends on your debts, your other assets, your tax position and the life you want to live. But the lump sum versus income question is usually the wrong place to start.

A good plan as you approach retirement and hit retirement will actually look at all the assets you’ve got, potential tax consequences of selling them, how they’re actually gonna perform for you in retirement and make sure you’re getting the income that you need.

The better question is whether your money is invested in a way that can fund your income for 30 or 40 years while keeping pace with inflation. Take a lump sum where it has a clear job to do, such as clearing a mortgage, and make sure everything else is invested well enough to last as long as you do.

Book a quick Wealth Planning Consultation and we’ll help you see where you stand, what’s possible, and how to make it happen.

  • Stop feeling uncertain about your financial future
  • You won’t need to make big sacrifices
  • You won’t drown in paperwork or endless meetings

Get started here.

About the Author: Ethan Stein is a financial planner with expertise in investment structuring, superannuation strategy, shares, property investment and other planning strategies. This article reflects general financial commentary only and does not constitute personal financial advice.

Financial Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for general knowledge and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Individual circumstances vary significantly. It is essential to consult with a qualified and licensed financial planner before making investment decisions. Past performance of any asset class is not indicative of future results.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Jane Doe

Ethan Stein

Director and Senior Financial Planner

Ethan is a Director and Financial Advisor at Montara Wealth. His role is to build out exceptional strategic advice for clients centred around their financial and lifestyle goals. Ethan is passionate about establishing financially dynamic, long term strategies for his clients.

N: 02 8330 3733
A: Suite 1, Level 6/309-315 George St, Sydney NSW 2000 | GPO Box 4473, Sydney NSW 2001
VIEW ALL POSTS BY ETHAN STEIN

BOOK AN APPOINTMENT

 

Financial Advisers & Planners – Hire Fee Based Best Financial Advisors – Estate Planning Firms,
Wealth Management & Advice Experts, SMSF Specialists- Financial Consultant & Strategy that
is Best for You in Bondi, Balmain & Sydney – Montara Wealth

 

Suite 1, Level 6/309-315 George St, Sydney NSW 2000 | GPO Box 4473, Sydney NSW 2001
Montara Wealth Pty Ltd, ABN 14 625 010 344 is Corporate Authorised Representative of Montara Services Pty Ltd Licence No. 526747

Privacy Policy | Licensing Disclaimer | Financial Services Guide | Advisor Profile